Court decision search

Ask your question in plain language. The answer quotes the decisions word for word.

Free, based on about 378,000 decisions. Updated every night.

Sign in

Sign in
You can also create an account here.

Below: what it is for, what it is not for, and where the data comes from.

Find a decision by case number

If you know the case number, the official collection number or the name of the case, you can open the decision without signing in. This lookup is not artificial intelligence: it matches what you type against the decisions' references, in several spellings, and does not count towards the weekly quota.

What is this?

dontes.app is a search tool for Hungarian and European court decisions. It does not look for your words but for what your question means: it picks the most relevant decisions and writes a short answer from them. Every quotation in the answer appears word for word in the decision, with the case number and the paragraph next to it, and the full text of the decision opens with one click.

Examples

One question from each of the four most searched areas. The answers are dontes.app's own answers, shortened; the cuts are marked.

Property law

„Can a strip of the neighbour's land be acquired by adverse possession if the fence has stood in the wrong place for decades?”

Yes, in principle: a strip beyond the registered boundary may be acquired by adverse possession if it was possessed as the possessor’s own, continuously and for the applicable statutory period. A fence standing in the wrong place for decades is important evidence of possession, but it does not automatically establish acquisition; the claimant must prove the duration, continuity and owner-like character of possession. The Hungarian ordinary-court decisions stress proof of these elements, while the ECtHR materials likewise distinguish physical possession from a mere expectation of ownership (ordinary court, Fővárosi Ítélőtábla Pf.20847/2011/4; ordinary court, Szekszárdi Járásbíróság P.20602/2013/14; ECtHR, Manukyan v. Armenia, no. 60456/12).

„A jogerős ítélet indokolása szerint nem bizonyított, hogy az elbirtoklás feltételei fennállnak: a felperes ellentmondásos előadásokat tett arra, hogy az elbirtoklás mikor következett be, illetve mikor létesítette a kerítést; nem állapítható meg egyértelműen, hogy a területrészt "sajátjaként" birtokolta, a per adatai szerint 1975-től V.S. használta.”
Curia of Hungary · Pfv.21511/2007/7 · 2008 · Reasoning
„In addition, the Court notes that there is nothing in the material before it to suggest that the applicant has ever been in physical possession of the disputed plot of land. Nor does it appear that he has ever occupied or otherwise used the plot of land in question. In particular, the applicant’s house and the attached plot of land were fenced with a wall (see paragraphs 4 and 13 above) whereas the disputed plot of land which was situated outside the fence, as stated by the Government and not specifically contested by the applicant, had served as a pathway leading to the neighbours’ garage for approximately twenty-six years (see paragraphs 33 and 34 above). In these circumstances, the Court finds that the applicant could not have any “legitimate expectation” to acquire the disputed plot of land through adverse possession.”
European Court of Human Rights · Manukyan v. Armenia, no. 60456/12 · 2021 · Reasoning

[…] The full answer contains further quotations and analysis.

Administrative law

„Can the right to deduct VAT be refused if the recipient of the invoice neither knew nor ought to have known that the issuer committed tax fraud?”

No: where the substantive and formal conditions for deduction are satisfied, the CJEU holds that refusal is impermissible unless the tax authority proves, on objective evidence, that the recipient knew or ought to have known of the VAT fraud (C-80/11 — Mahagében kft v Nemzeti Adó- és Vámhivatal Dél-dunántúli Regionális Adó Főigazgatósága; C-512/21 — Aquila Part Prod Com SA v Nemzeti Adó- és Vámhivatal Fellebbviteli Igazgatósága). The recipient cannot generally be required to investigate the supplier’s tax compliance or perform checks that are not its responsibility (C-324/11 — Gábor Tóth v Nemzeti Adó- és Vámhivatal Észak-magyarországi Regionális Adó Főigazgatósága; Kúria guidance 2014.El.II.JGY.1/2.). The ECtHR reached a compatible result under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, while the Constitutional Court material and the ordinary-court material here do not add a contrary holding.

„Accordingly, the answer to the second question is that Directive 2006/112 must be interpreted as meaning that it precludes the tax authority from refusing a taxable person the right to deduct VAT due or paid for services provided to him on the ground that the issuer of the invoice relating to those services did not declare the workers he employed, without that authority establishing, on the basis of objective evidence, that the taxable person concerned knew, or ought to have known, that the transaction relied on as a basis for the right to deduct was connected with fraud committed by the issuer of the invoice or by another trader acting earlier in the chain of supply.”
Court of Justice of the EU · C-324/11, Tóth · 2011 · Reasoning · 39. para.
„Given that the refusal of the right to deduct in accordance with paragraph 45 of the present judgment is an exception to the application of the fundamental principle constituted by that right, it is for the tax authority to establish, to the requisite legal standard, the objective evidence which allows the conclusion to be drawn that the taxable person knew, or ought to have known, that the transaction relied on as a basis for the right to deduct was connected with fraud committed by the supplier or by another trader acting earlier in the chain of supply.”
Court of Justice of the EU · C-80/11, Mahagében · 2011 · Operative part · 49. para.

[…] The full answer contains further quotations and analysis.

Company law

„When is a company's executive officer liable to the company's creditors?”

An executive officer’s special liability to creditors generally arises after the company enters a situation threatening insolvency, where the officer culpably disregards creditors’ interests and this causes the company’s assets to decrease or prevents creditors’ full satisfaction (Cstv. 33/A. § (1); G.40063/2011/36; 3462/2022. (XI. 17.) AB határozat). Ordinary courts characterise this as an exceptional, insolvency-related form of liability, while the Constitutional Court confirms the relevant temporal and causal requirements. The Curia’s non-binding guidance stresses that the officer must balance the company’s interests with those of creditors; separately, KDB decision D.55/2020 states that outside insolvency-specific rules the company is ordinarily liable for harm caused in the officer’s representative capacity, with direct joint liability particularly for intentional harm.

„A fenti jogszabályi rendelkezésekből következik, hogy a társasági jogi rendelkezésekkel összhangban a Cstv. 33/A. §-a megteremtette a gazdasági társaságok vezetőinek a hitelezőkkel szembeni, magánvagyonukra is kiterjedő - polgári jogi - felelősségét arra az esetre, ha a fizetésképtelenséggel fenyegető helyzet bekövetkeztét követően ügyvezetési feladatokat nem a hitelezők érdekeinek elsődlegessége alapján látják el és ezáltal a társasági vagyon csökkent (wrongful trading). A vezető tisztségviselők felelősségét a törvény úgy állapítja meg, hogy egyben kifejezésre juttatja ezen felelősségi forma "rendkívüli" jellegét, így azt, hogy marasztalásra csak abban az esetben kerülhet sor, ha felszámolás után ki nem elégített hitelezői követelések maradnak fenn.”
Debrecen Regional Court · G.40063/2011/36 · 2012 · Reasoning
„Ezért a Ptk. 3:118. § szerint már „csak” az a követelmény, hogy a „fizetésképtelenséggel fenyegető helyzet” beállta után a vezető tisztségviselő a gazdasági társaság hitelezőinek érdekeire is köteles figyelemmel lenni. E megfogalmazás alapján tehát a vezető tisztségviselőnek két egymással ellentétes érdekrendszernek kell megfelelnie, egyfelől a gazdasági társaság érdekeinek elsődlegessége alapján kell eljárnia, másfelől figyelemmel kell lennie a hitelezők érdekeit is.”
Curia guidance (non-binding) · Case-law analysis group summary opinion on directors' liability to creditors · 2016

[…] The full answer contains further quotations and analysis.

Criminal law

„When does a factual statement about a public figure amount to defamation?”

A factual statement about a public figure amounts to defamation when it conveys a specific, verifiable allegation that harms reputation—particularly an accusation of criminal, illegal, immoral or dishonourable conduct—and lacks a sufficient factual basis. Public figures must tolerate wider criticism, especially on matters of public interest, but that wider margin does not protect unsupported factual allegations (ECtHR, Azadliq and Zayidov v. Azerbaijan, no. 20755/08; ECtHR, Standard Verlagsgesellschaft Mbh v. Austria, no. 19068/13). The Constitutional Court similarly focuses on false, reputation-harming facts or true facts presented misleadingly, while the Hungarian Supreme Court treats allegations capable of triggering criminal proceedings as exceeding protected expression (Constitutional Court, 3165/2021. (IV. 30.) AB; ordinary court, Kúria Bfv.1828/2017/8).

„The Court confirms that the present case concerns a statement of fact not a value judgment, moreover a statement of fact which was devoid of any truthful basis: the Court observes that it was not ultimately disputed before the domestic courts that the investigation in question had not taken place. Moreover, the issue of the alleged extreme right-wing affiliation of the plaintiff’s father was excluded by those courts from the scope of their examination. As regards the sole remaining issue – namely whether the real motive for the plaintiff’s omission to sanction the investigation in question was his father’s participation in the Hungarista movement – the Court sees no reason to depart from the domestic courts’ view that the applicant’s statement was essentially factual. Such an utterance was, for the Court, susceptible of proof, which the applicant did not offer the domestic courts.”
European Court of Human Rights · Keller v. Hungary, no. 33352/02 · 2006 · Reasoning
„A közszereplővel kapcsolatban olyan tényre utaló kifejezések közlése, amelyek - valóságuk esetén - alkalmasak a közszereplő ellen büntetőeljárás indítására, túlmegy a szabad véleménynyilvánítás alkotmányos szabadságán, meghaladják a szabad véleménynyilvánítás alkotmányos határait; olyan tényállítások, amelyek az objektív értelmezés mellett becsületsértőek, hiszen - valóságuk esetén - a sértett ellen büntetőeljárás megindítására is alkalmasak (BH 2011.186.). A tény fogalma alá tartozik valamely, a múltban bekövetkezett vagy a jelenben (a megnyilatkozáskor) tartó cselekmény (cselekedet, magatartás), történés (jelenség, esemény), továbbá állapot (így az ember múltban fennállt, vagy jelenben fennálló tudatállapota is) (BH 1994.171.). A tényállítás olyan megnyilatkozás, amelynek tartalma múltban bekövetkezett vagy jelenben tartó cselekmény, történés, állapot. Jövőbeni cselekményre, történésre, állapotra vonatkozó megnyilatkozás nem tényállítás, hanem feltételezés; nem rágalmazás, hanem legfeljebb becsületsértés alapja lehet.”
Curia of Hungary · Bfv.1828/2017/8 · 2018 · Reasoning

[…] The full answer contains further quotations and analysis.

How does it work?

  1. 1Your question is searched in three ways: by meaning, by wording, and by case number if it contains one.
  2. 2Out of several hundred thousand decisions, an AI finds the ten most closely related ones.
  3. 3A second AI writes the answer from those ten decisions.
  4. 4Checking software compares every quotation letter by letter and keeps only what appears word for word in the original decision.
  5. 5Each decision is shown with its appeal chain, so you can see whether a higher court upheld or changed it.

Works inside Claude and ChatGPT

The search can also be used from Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants that support the MCP standard; the assistant then searches and reads the decisions itself. This gives even more precise answers at a lower running cost. How to connect: Machine access.

What it is for, and what it is not for

What it is for

  • getting an overview of the case law on a legal question;
  • getting to know a new area of law in broad strokes;
  • collecting precise, traceable quotations;
  • following a case through the courts;
  • comparing Hungarian, EU and Strasbourg case law;
  • pulling up a known decision by its case number.

What it is not for

  • Legal advice. It does not replace a lawyer, nor reading the source.
  • Use without checking. The summary and the analysis can be wrong. Only the quotations are verified; in case of doubt the original text prevails.
  • A complete survey. The official Hungarian collection is selective and anonymised, and decisions not yet published are missing.
  • Listing cases. It cannot answer “in which cases did … happen” well, because every answer rests on the ten most relevant decisions only.
  • Searching legislation, commentaries or literature. It searches decisions only.
  • Unlimited use. There is a weekly question limit; that is what keeps the service free.

Donate

dontes.app is free, and the same for everyone. Answering one question costs about 3 euro cents, and running the service about €135 a month. If you find it useful, please help keep it running.

Serverabout €55
Ranking search resultsabout €17
Writing answersabout €33
Other (domain name, adding new decisions, etc.)about €30
Total per monthabout €135

Monthly donations help most, even small ones.

Support dontes.app

Sources

Updated: 20 November 2026
SourceDecisionsUpdated
Hungarian ordinary courts and the Curia (official collection of court decisions, supplemented from the Curia's own lists)246,162daily
European Court of Human Rights71,796daily
Court of Justice and General Court of the EU41,711daily
Hungarian Constitutional Court, since 199013,564daily
Hungarian Public Procurement Arbitration Board, since 20184,366daily
Curia guidance (non-binding)406daily
EFTA Court389weekly
Total378,394

The figures are refreshed every night with the daily update. The sources are described in detail in the Guide.

How your questions are handled

This is a case-law search tool, not confidential correspondence. Do not include information covered by legal professional privilege in your questions. Details: Privacy notice.

Warning

The system uses AI. The answers are generated by artificial intelligence and can be wrong.